Talk:CD-i

Zelda CD-i Titles
I think the description entry to this one is pretty bad. Regardless of the opinion you have on the game saying there is nothing wrong about it an calling all criticism unfounded is a really hysterical claim an quite misleading; the article should acknowledge the flaws of the game and warn the readers about them.

The worst part is the unecessary link provided to try and convince readers that the game is good, it's enormously apologetic to a pathetic level, killing Ganon in one hit is original?, Come on son, that's one real desperate opinion.

He gets all these people who worked with the game to try to explain their deal as if it was proof of the game's worth, it basically boils down to "if you ignore all the glaring flaws of the game it's a really good game", I don't buy it and no one else who reads this will probably ever do especially when he ironically states that he thinks they are superior to Zelda II, again, it's a really unnecesary addition to the description.

TL;DR: It's true these games are not even amonst the worst games ever made but this description is pretty biased and misleading, I'm not changing it myself because it will probably just be shunned off as trolling so this is just a piece of my mind


 * Next time remember to sign with four tildes whenever you write in a talk page.
 * The link is not unnecessary at all; many pages on this wiki link to various reviews and gameplay videos.
 * Killing the final boss in one hit is very original, for the time this game came out. Note he can only be one-shot by that particular item, and is immune to everything else. Also remember that at that time there was no GameFAQs or something similar, so you'd have to try everything for yourself.
 * He gets all these people who worked with the game to provide background information on the game, like they do in the majority of their reviews, more as a curiosity bit and not to prove any point.
 * The only glaring flaw of these games are the ridiculous cutscenes, which are mentioned in the description.
 * The majority of people who criticize these games never played the games (there is no working emulator yet, and a working CD-i is not only difficult to find, but also prone to failure like the Jaguar CD) and just jump on the hate bandwagon. Much like what happens with E.T.
 * I agree that the description needs work, like a lot of things on this wiki. Please do tell any idea you have to improve it.

Welcome to your doom! 16:00, August 20, 2014 (UTC)